BVI News

COMMENTARY: Evidence of deflation in BVI

Austerity is an option in long-term economic planning. However, history has given austerity a ‘bad rap’. Austerity ideas present solutions for a long-term economic plan for the British Virgin Islands.

Why: because the Virgin Islands economy possesses a number of characteristics of an austere economy. The economy is top-down and driven by the wealthy North American and Western European investor.

The Virgin Islands is a very unequal society with enormous gaps between the one percent and the 90 percent. Then, there is increasing poverty at the base of the social pyramid as wealth continues to concentrate at the top of the wealth pyramid.

There are features of a Stimulus Economy too.

Government in the Virgin Islands is a second critical driver of the economy and is the largest employer in the territory. Government directs and navigates economic growth in the Virgin Islands ‘hand in hand’ with foreign investors.


Austerity is the belief that fiscal probity boosts business confidence. In other words, miserliness is good for the soul. Cutting debt, and living frugally, is great economic medicine in the world of Jack the Austerity Worshipper.

However, this Economics Layman and writer believe that Austerity is the very last thing the Virgin Islands requires, post the September 2017 natural disasters.

Yes, transparency and accountability are critical in how the economy is stimulated. And there must be strict checks in place in how the cash for physical, social, and economic recovery is managed; earned, donated, borrowed. So, stimulus must be tightly audited and managed.

Now, under the austere culture, at the extreme end, governments cut spending and raise taxes simultaneously, all in the name of reducing deficits and national debt.

Driver of economic efficiency

The belief is that achieving the preceding is great for investor and business confidence, and consequently great for everyone else, no matter the social hardships. Austerity is considered a driver of economic efficiency. Whether this is so or not is a matter of opinion.

But, austere cultures, according to the brightest minds in economics, have created unacceptable wealth inequality, the haemorrhaging of the western middle classes, and deflationary pressures, driven by fear and debt.

Austerity has rewritten the economics narrative in the favour of the one percent, who own and direct global wealth.

Still, austerity holds ideas and solutions for short, medium, and long-term economic planning. And economic planning is a dire necessity if these Virgin Islands are to progress and develop after a September 2017 of disaster.


Stimulus – the economics of John Maynard Keynes and his government intervention, consumer-driven model – sits on the opposing polarity. Jack Stimulus views the working men and women who are the 90 percent, as the true drivers of a sustainable and strong economy.

Their consumption of goods and services is omnipotent.

This is the reverse to the thinking of Tom Austere – the disciple of Milton Friedman’s Chicago school. Tom the Austerian holds to the iron rule that the production of goods and services – the supply-driven free trading model – is almighty.

The wealthy businessman is King of the economy. Trickle down is the natural order of the Darwinian Economic Model of Jack the Austere.

OK, one result of three decades of austere economics was the supply gap. Goods and services remained on shelves, and elsewhere, in western countries.

These abandoned products required buyers, who had been pummeled by uncertainty, unemployment, and debt: the offspring of austere cultures.


As a consequence, prices began to fall. But the goods remained on shelves. Deflation was born. Deflation is a threat to all economies.

Deflation is caused by a contraction in demand and is a major factor in long-term economic stagnation and depression.

Deflation is the result of a number of factors. Austerity is one driver of deflation. But there are further drivers of deflation such as demographics, war, and natural disaster.

And there is some evidence that there is deflation in the Virgin Islands, as traumatized consumers stop their spending post-Irma and Maria and the September floods.

Greedy retailers

In the territory, deflation pressures are not helped by greedy retailers who essentially sell low-quality products at extortionate prices. Goods that sell in dollar stores in the USA are priced as quality items in stores in the Virgin Islands: this is laughable.

There is certainly a need for consumer protection in the Virgin Islands in this Writer’s opinion. But in any event, the market will deal with greedy, inefficient retailers, who will simply go out of business in the age of Amazon, and internet commerce.

Retailers and shop owners who miss the mark will taste from the process termed creative destruction. Competition in economics is unassailable in the age of the microchip. The market is a boss.

Copyright 2021 BVI News, Media Expressions Limited. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or distributed.

1 Comment

Disclaimer: BVI News and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the comments below or other interaction among the users.

  1. What he say? says:

    “Fiscal probity… miserliness is good for the soul”

    We need front line action and innovative solutions to our immediate problems. We applaud the author for seeking solutions but suggest he limit his range to match his syntax.

Leave a Comment