Education Minister slams ‘disrespectful’ Opposition member

Education Minister Sharie deCastro has called for greater respect among members of the House of Assembly following an incident where she was allegedly told to “sit down and shut up” by an Opposition member during a recess.

Addressing the House yesterday, deCastro highlighted the importance of maintaining decorum, referencing Standing Order 48-4, which prohibits offensive and insulting language among members. She stated, “While the opposition and the government may disagree, it must be done in a respectful manner.”

The Minister expressed dismay at the incident, asserting, “I do not take it lightly at all.” She indicated her intention to formally address the matter, demanding an apology from Second District Representative Melvin ‘Mitch’ Turnbull, who was accused of making the offending remark.

In response, the Speaker acknowledged the complaint and reminded members to be respectful, noting that the matter would be addressed upon receiving deCastro’s formal letter.

Treat members respectfully, especially women

Premier Dr Natalio Wheatley supported deCastro, emphasising the need for respectful treatment of all members, especially women. He stated, “I think we should go above and beyond to ensure that we do not accord anyone of a different gender less than favourable treatment.”

Premier Wheatley also suggested that Turnbull should make a public apology immediately since the alleged remarks were already in the public domain.

DeCastro was also supported by Territorial At-Large Representative Lorna Smith, who said she had not heard the remark but believed it should not be minimised. Smith stressed the importance of maintaining proper decorum within the House, stating, “Whether it was in jest or not, as you said, on these precincts, we must observe proper decorum.”

Smith also commended both government and Opposition members for ultimately reaching a consensus on the day’s business, noting that the matter should serve as a reminder for all members to engage in respectful dialogue. “I am happy that consensus has been arrived at today because I would have been embarrassed to walk out this door unless we had arrived at the decision,” she stated.

When given the opportunity to respond, Turnbull chose to wait until the formal complaint was submitted before addressing the issue.