US fisherman allowed to go home after four months in BVI prison
A United States fisherman who has spent four months at Her Majesty’s Prison in Balsam Ghut was last week released after Magistrate Christilyn Benjamin ordered him to pay a $4,000 fine.
The fisherman, Michael Foy was charged with illegal entry, arriving at a place other than a Customs port, and operating an unlicensed or unregulated fishing vessel.
He initially pleaded not guilty to all charges. However, the judge later dismissed the fishing charge while Foy pleaded guilty to the other two.
Last Wednesday, Magistrate Benjamin handed down her sentence for the two remaining charges, ruling that Foy was free to leave the territory after paying a .
the $4,000 fine.
The 60-year-old fisherman was arrested in June near Norman Island. His boat, the Rebel, was impounded and is in danger of forfeiture as prosecutors sought to have a $511,000 fine laid against him for illegal entry.
For the charge of illegal entry, Magistrate Benjamin decided to forego a fine and imposed a four-month custodial sentence, counting the four months that he had already served.
If Foy does not pay the $4,000 fine by November 10, he will be back put back in prison for an additional six months.
While Foy was being detained, his family in the United States had alleged the fisherman had been mistreated by BVI officials.
Copyright 2024 BVI News, Media Expressions Limited. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or distributed.
The lack of consistency and uneven punishment across the board in this country is ridiculous. Everything, despite law related guidelines and statutes, seem to be so randomly and unevenly applied it is truly frightening. At one moment an individual gets hammered for the pettiest of crimes, and another given a slap on the hand for the most egregious!
Why is it that regardless of colour, creed, religion, or citizenship that the ‘legal system’ cannot be more even and consistent?
There is nothing outrageous about this particular punishment. He plead guilty to 2 charges. If he plead guilty months ago instead of dragging it on he probably wouldn’t have slept much in jail.
Read the article! he wasn’t guilty of one of the charges so why would he have plead guilty to it?
3 square meals per day
No bills to pay
No wife to obey
BVI is really Nice eh
Well it’s Nature’s little secret anyway.
Prosecutors sought to have a $511,000 fine laid against him for illegal entry, doesn’t that seem extremely excessive?
But if you walk about with an illegal gun you get bail. Wrong color Mr Fisherman. For the Zimbabvi.
Why would you offer a non resident, someone with no ties to the BVI bail during a fluent curfew period. This is a consistent action by the Court to not offer bail in these cases. Nothing to do with color.
He didn’t have enough melanin. That was his mistake.
Meanwhile the DPP is still thinking about how to sell the fish!
What happened to the boat ?
Now after a 4 month sentence he must be deported and by being deported he can no longer gain entry to the BVI. This means he can no longer get round the JONAS act by clearing into the BVI.
Keep himout of BVI waters and by that I mean the fishing grounds 200 miles off the back of Anegada.
Can you please tell me where in the article did it say that he is going to be deported?
Did you read where I said he “should be” deported or did that pass you by on your eagerness to correct?
Why can’t we have proper journalism? What happened about the slaves he had on board? What was it he actually did and didn’t do right/wrong? What’s the status of illegal and unsustainable fishing in or via our waters? This article tells us next to nothing.
Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye?