BVI News

COMMENTARY: Citizens of welfare states are happier

By Dickson Igwe, Contributor

Accurate statistics, and sound economic metrics, are critical to engineering economic recovery. Accurate knowledge and the appropriate measure of a country’s economy, offers policymakers information that drives good governance and social prosperity.

Now, in making any type of assertion on GDP – the total value of goods and services produced by a country – it is valid to state that growing GDP does not necessarily imply a better quality of life.

A tiny number of economists are increasingly aware that good governance is more than simply generating economic growth.

Good governance is about promoting national well being: contentment, happiness, and social welfare. The idea of a ‘happiness index’ is the measurement of intangibles such as quality of life, and human welfare, that GDP does not measure.

A country with a large GDP metric, when compared to neighbours in its region, such as Nigeria – $400 billion – can suffer from terrible social and physical infrastructure. On the other hand, a country such as Costa Rica – $50 billion – that is poorer than many neighbours in terms of natural and financial resources, possesses first world social and economic infrastructure, and a much higher quality of life metric.

Social welfare

Social welfare is more than the improvement in the material wealth of the society.

GDP has to be linked to improving quality of life, for GDP to be a tool for improving the lives of the population. Good governance is using GDP in the most efficient, effective, and innovative way, in the pursuit of the greater quality of life of all the citizens and residents of a country.

And indebtedness, when it is private indebtedness directly impacts quality of life.

Personal debt is a source of worry. Personal debt produces anxiety. It can become a great burden on individuals, families, and businesses.

A 2012 study using an international data set from Gallup found that citizens of nations with progressive tax policies, that invest in public services: education, transportation, experience greater wellbeing. Citizens of the welfare state are happier.

This is because good public services touch many more people than what any privately driven system will provide.

Governments that provide for the social welfare of the most vulnerable, and the betterment of the working and middle classes, in terms of education, social care, cultural investment, healthcare, green spaces, and so on and so forth, build stronger communities and societies.

This is directly opposed to supply sided ideologically driven governments that view human beings as simple statistics: units of consumption that drive economic growth through their spending habits, and business productivity.

3 billion needs to be borrowed in 10 years

The preceding leaves communities poor and vulnerable. Now, lending money to transparent and democratic governments in free societies is deemed safe lending, especially when there is a healthy projected annual GDP, based on historical numbers, and a level of financial solvency that will service borrowing.

Better still, where debt to GDP ratios are backed up by accurate numbers from treasury and financial agencies. That is something that is absent in the British Virgin Islands. post-Irma, and looking into the next 20 years, the cost of recovery will come from borrowing.

The exact figure of the money required for full recovery cannot be readily determined, but if it has been estimated that total destruction from Irma is in the three to four-billion-dollar range, then it can safely be stated that the Virgin Islands will need to borrow in terms of both public borrowing (government), and private borrowing (business and household) in the region of at least three billion over the upcoming decade, to replace damaged infrastructure and place the country firmly on the path to development and prosperity.

Consequently the country’s financial managers must have accurate numbers on indebtedness in order to accurately manage the country’s finances and resources.

What is the total national debt: the total figure of all the country’s internal and external borrowings? What is the short term debt figure: loans that are to be paid in say one to three years?

What was the government total expenditure in the past year and what were its total revenues. Compare the preceding with the past five years.

What are the totals of all the various types of taxes and payments into the treasury, such as payments from offshore interests, public agencies, and public utilities? Again assess and compare with the prior years in terms of debt to GDP?

Possessing accurate economic statistics that Joe Public can understand is a prerequisite for any type of economic recovery and social development. That is because it offers government a guiding narrative, a road map, to El Dorado.

Copyright 2021 BVI News, Media Expressions Limited. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or distributed.


Disclaimer: BVI News and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the comments below or other interaction among the users.

  1. Magellan says:

    I’m just looking for a road map to Road Town on roads that aren’t broken, past dumps that aren’t burning, through east side towns that don’t stink with sewage in the street.

  2. Albion says:

    The problem with socialism is that, as Margaret Thatcher said: “sooner or later you run out of other people’s money.”

    Like 6
    Dislike 4
  3. Wes says:

    Socialism in its pure form is a snake eating it tail. Eventually everyone is on welfare with no motivation to produce and the money runs out.

    Like 2
    Dislike 6
    • Onething says:

      Nope. Explain Germany, netherlands, austria,norway…..these countries are just as rich as America….norway is richer than America….and very productive also. Taxes are high but with that Edication is free up to university and seeing a doctor is free.

      Like 7
      Dislike 1
      • Not says:

        Nothing in this life is free.

        • Onething says:

          The high taxes pay for it. You dont pay for school up to uni or pay to see a doctor in some european countries. Lots of you people don’t know anthing other than America so you assume the world over is like that

  4. Economics says:

    The welfare state may work in a small country like Norway, rich in resources, relatively homogeneous in culture and race, but how is it working out for say Greece? Free government services are great IF you can pay for them.

    Here in the BVI, our main revenue source comes from financial services. Why? Because offshore companies come with a much lower tax structure. Though the author does not admit it, it is this supply side/trickle down economic policy that has led to our own “welfare state” with NHI, free education, government being the largest employer etc.

    With the UK now clamping down and our society in panic,the question remains, “How is our welfare state going to continue without supply side economic policy?”

    Sorry Mr. Igwe, I don’t see how we are going to spend our way to prosperity and happiness.

    Like 1
    Dislike 2
  5. Economics 101 says:

    I agree with “Economics” above. A welfare state destroys individuals’ incentives and motivation to work, create, and innovate, which are major drivers of wealth creation for all. Teach the people to fish on their own, instead of handing out government issued fish (taken from someone else).

    • Onething says:

      That’s not how socialism works. Obviously you don’t know much about Economics. Explain the high productivity in Germany, austria and netherlands.

Leave a Comment