BVI News

Trio accused of killing Trumayne ‘Passion’ Daway freed

Breaking news.

The three persons accused in the Trumayne ‘Passion’ Daway murder trial were freed today in the High Court.

Vernon Bernard, Maybelline Rodriguez and Rafael Harrigan were charged with murder and illegal possession of a firearm.

But Justice Richard Floyd upheld a no-case submission submitted by the defence attorneys representing the trio. The judge, thereafter, indicated to the jury to return a not guilty verdict on the two charges.

Justice Floyd indicated he considered the evidence presented by the prosecution before the court and it was not strong enough to proceed with a case against the three accused.

Deputy Director of Public Prosecution and principal prosecutor on the case Kellei-Gaye Smith said the Crown will consider appealing the decision.

Harrigan was represented by Michael Lashley QC and Michael Maduro, Bernard was represented by Richard Rowe, and Rodriguez was represented by Valerie Stephens-Gordon QC.

More to come.

No motive found! Defence attorney pokes holes in Crown’s case

Shares

Copyright 2024 BVI News, Media Expressions Limited. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or distributed.

54 Comments

Disclaimer: BVI News and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the comments below or other interaction among the users.

  1. weak says:

    the prosecution was very weak. from the police to the deputy director. look at how an inspector of police give evidence. wow.he was far from prepared. I would say one last thing here now.all the promotion that these police are getting is laughable. most of them are I’ll prepared to deal with matters like this in a court of law.on Facebook yes they are specialist in every field but put them with a few good lawyers and they shake like bamboo leaf.the police are the ones that do the ground work and if it is not done properly the prosecutor would have a weak case.so do not blame the prosecution alone.

    Like 35
    Dislike 6
    • SMH says:

      Not because the cops didn’t do things the right way means they are inno_ _ _ t. Those of you with common sense can put 2 and 2 together. This is just sad and I hope other families of victims are not discouraged about the justice system….cause the justice system can fail, but KARMA wouldn’t

      Like 21
      Dislike 4
      • @smh says:

        can you tell me what is the 2 and 2 you got.

        Nothing was found Nothing from the Jump the police had nothing on these 3 nothing.

        his our family said the 3 had no bad blood towards him.

        so tell me how how you can sit and feel good that 3 person sit and wait for 4 years to hear what they already had know not guilty.

        no one knows what really happen the police hed these persons and that was it. never went and try get clue just went off a cell phone messages.. and that it.

        I just hope if you ever get in any kind of trouble and don’t tell me you would cause anything can happen to anyone. I hope you want people to believe you.

        Like 3
        Dislike 18
    • Mat block says:

      Now, if he went to that location and a used condom was found, piece of toilet paper and baby wipes …..what did he go there for??? Its obvious he was to meet a woman and after they did their business , she used the baby wipes …..so nobody thought to test them for DNA???

  2. wow says:

    michael maduro jammin

    Like 11
    Dislike 8
  3. bottom line says:

    We have an incompetent police force

    Like 47
    Dislike 4
  4. WOW says:

    Is the DPP that weak???

    Like 41
    Dislike 1
    • .... says:

      It starts with the Police force. The DDP can’t successfully prosecute a case with evidence these Incompetent police provide unfortunately.

      Like 12
      Dislike 6
      • x says:

        The DPP decides whether or not to prosecute based on the evidence the police provides. The DPP is at fault too.

        Like 11
      • LAW AND ORDERR says:

        I disagree. The DPP is in a position to guide the police in the way forward. Not just to look like prosecutors in their black robes. That’s only part of it. They are woefully ill prepared to handle real cases but can easily destroy the family lives of honest people who made mistakes along the way. Their specialty is selective prosecution, now the prayers of all those who they destroyed along with their families are bearing fruit. The files go to the DPP’s Office for instructions just like they send the files of minor matters to destroy officers that could have been advised another way. Well We are in mucho problemo with that set. This is the definition of INCOPETENCE! Lack of humility on the part of the DPP and pride. Nuff said. By the way, this does not mean that the trio was not involved. It was only that they could not convince the court enough. Many guilty accused go free because the playing field was not level.

        Like 5
        Dislike 1
  5. Listen says:

    Thank you lord the truth is out…

    To All (3) Please take sometime with your family for the time that was lost. and sue the government after…

    4 years of your life gone!

    4 years of your name being call as a murder.

    This to shall pass but it is what I been saying god don’t sleep and the truth SHALL SET YOU FREE!!!

    And it did…..

    Like 6
    Dislike 58
    • @Listen says:

      They ARE ***!!! Too bad our DPP is weak! What a slap to the victim’s family.

      Like 18
      Dislike 2
      • listen says:

        how do you know where you they. like them police had nothing to go on. even the family said it they was no bad blood between none of them. but you hear this and that on the street and people like ayo go run with it.

        READ it well no finger print No Eye witness not prove that these are the person kill this young man… like give it a break now. the police know from the being they had the wrong set of persons…

        The police worst them time on these three instead of looking for more information and clues..

        now 4 years have gone by and now still nothing how can you sit and still say them murder someone when you cant prove it. …

        Like 5
        Dislike 5
        • Jokes says:

          The family don’t know diddle. They too were assuming. Who knows who their children have bad blood with and when friends fall out? stupes. I hope they are indeed innocent!

    • really says:

      the truth did not come out.all who follow the matter from day one knows who the guilty ones are.so stop your nonsense about thank you lord the truth is out.a re trial will have to take place sooner rather than later. so hold your breath a little longer.and please don’t forget that it’s the bvi we are living in with over 60 plus unsolved murders.

      Like 11
      • @really says:

        i follow from day one as well.

        and they is nothing to prove they kill him NOTHING……….

        Now retrial will show what, Nothing again.. the police had nothing on them.

        Nothing

        Like 4
        Dislike 3
    • Ridiculous says:

      Because the DPP was weak means that the trio didn’t do it? So I guess he killed himself then. Hmm shame on you but doesn’t sleep nor slumber

      Like 14
      Dislike 1
    • Nomaaan says:

      They can’t sue the Government. The police had reasonable cause to believe they did it. That is all that is required for the police to hold them.

      Like 7
      Dislike 2
      • U will know says:

        You will know who can abs cannot sue, the mere man on the road will always believe the defense can’t sue but there are so many loop holes and areas, malicious prosecution, damages, pain abs suffering, lost in income and economic status and earnings, and mobility wait and hear the figures the govt purse will have to fork out just wait

  6. Police weak. Crown weaker! says:

    Police is very week. From the start. There were two officers that were exceptional but all the rest needs to go home.

    Prosecution wasn’t no better. Can’t build a case to save their soul. What a waste.

    • listen says:

      But build from what. you have to have proof to build a case and never had it from the start..

      so you cant Blame the DPP Blame the police that only kept these 3 and never look at other information or clue to see if its possible someone else could have done it.

      the family said it them self these three had no bad blood what was the reason for killing him..

      now the street say this and that and you blaming the DPP FOR WHAT as I say the police took this 3 person up and that was it never look or try to see if there were any body else to connect to this case.

      i for one 4 years of my life gone and person will look at them different out here but if you don have proof to show i did something you can hold me up for it..

      Like 5
      Dislike 5
      • @Listen says:

        You on every comment replying. No doubt that you are a family member. Hope you never have to go through this. Idiot!

        Like 12
        Dislike 1
      • Strupes says:

        They were charged because they ***! The prosecution/ police were weak. And were there texts messages suggesting that they K**LLED Passion? … You’re just a delusional family member or friend of these ***… simple.

        God doesn’t sleep. And Karma is always around the corner. Stay tuned…

        Like 5
        Dislike 1
        • ...... says:

          No, there weren’t any such text messages.

        • Stay tuned for what says:

          Some of you on here blogging in circles under different names threatening violence of hoping that someone does the violence against these men on your behalf, half the time you can’t stand blood and can’t kill a cow ready for skitter so why come on here blogging like you into that game. The court has decided so let it be stop in sighting further violence

          • Wow says:

            Court have decided. Wow this is people life, a life was taken… what you mean let it be. Clearly you never lost anyone in that manner or you just only seeing the trio side cause you know them

          • @stay tuned for what says:

            i agree with you 100% what the police need to come out and say is they never had anything their made up stuff now the community here thinking them know everything.

            the text messages was not of passion but black boy who was in court to say his part.

            to passion family i hope one day the truth comes out. but we need to understand the police had nothing on these 3 person nothing. and it show yesterday that 4 years waste on 3 person while the real killer out here walking around us.

            if he had sex her with her, her DNA would have been in the car it was not not even her finger print or hair was found. to say she was their.

            eye witness say their were 3 man no one never say no woman.

            as you say people coming on here saying this and that but none have the balls to kill anyone or harm them. just talking with them mouths.

  7. SOON COME says:

    this country’s so called justice system continues to fail the victims of willful cold blooded murder / through these impostors who is using the position in society to dictate their own to suit themselves / so I believe some people will refer to street justice watch and see

    Like 9
    Dislike 1
  8. Stop It says:

    Try stop call the Lord name in your mess

  9. Rock Man MURDAH says:

    Get don’t have no date… Grrtttttt

  10. Rock Man MURDAH says:

    Get bacc don’t got no date.. Grrttttt

  11. Big Richard says:

    AGAIN, nice work DPP

    Like 3
    Dislike 1
  12. Hmm says:

    The police inspector did a poor job. Talking nonsense in court. He needs to do better than that.

    Like 4
    Dislike 1
  13. 45 says:

    God don’t sleep n neither will yell @ar0n n his pets will all get theirs

  14. Wow says:

    Only in the BVI!

  15. Hey says:

    Send them home!!!

  16. DPP says:

    We hiring must skillful enough to solve cases….they beat a Murder Case….

  17. I now see...... says:

    I now see why all these case are backed up so much, charging with lack of evidence to convict these so called criminals.

    And I got to say SO-CALL in this case, because if you know you have the right person. DO NOT GO IN COURT SAYING JUDGE I TELLIN YUH THEM DO IT I FEEL IT IN MY HEART.

    You must have that evidence mehn.

    If I was locked up right now, after or slightly before 2018 and I READ OR HEAR ABOUT THIS. I would be looking to get those defense lawyer to back me buddy.

  18. Incredulous says:

    How can a judge tell the jury to rule Not Guilty?. Of course they will find that wsy if instructed by a judge to do so. Why not let them vote THEN decide if a no case. Let the vote be honest.
    A mother left without a child. Brother left without brother. SON left without a father he adored.

    Like 3
    Dislike 1
  19. wow says:

    Look bird sanctuary lawyer, Richard doing big things.

  20. QUESTION says:

    My question can a judge, ask a jury to return a not guilty verdict. Is this legal.

  21. Truth says:

    When u have a set of police that never worked and ubput them in position because of favouritism thats the type of result u get. To many police i. Specialist post that dont even know how totake or give a proper statement. The police force needs to be looked at and theright persons needs to be put in the right places. The crown will continue to loose its cases.

Leave a Comment

Shares