Turnbull clashes with Education Minister over playground donation
A row erupted at the Ivan Dawson Primary School in Cane Garden Bay after Second District Representative Melvin ‘Mitch’ Turnbull accused Education Minister Sharie deCastro of manipulation and posturing over the installation of a donated playground.
Turnbull made the remarks on site after officers of the Royal Virgin Islands Police Force were called to the school compound, where a container holding the new playground equipment was offloaded, and instructions were issued to remove it.
He said the playground was sourced to replace an ageing and unsafe structure that had remained on the school grounds since the 2017 hurricanes.
“We announced on July 5 at the graduation that I was going to seek donations to get the playground for the Ivan Dawson Primary School because there has been a dilapidated ‘boat’, that was donated by the Convoy of Hope, since the 2017 hurricanes,” Turnbull said. “That playground now has caused a number of injuries because time has elapsed,” he stated.
Turnbull said the donation was secured through ATU BVI and that he wrote formally to the Ministry of Education seeking collaboration under its donation policy. He said the playground remained at the ports from early January, accumulating storage fees, before being transported to the school.
“This playground has been on the ports of the BVI since around the 9th of January and absorbing port fees,” he said. “We worked now to get the container cleared. The playground was offloaded yesterday on the school campus and now we are here today with instructions to remove the playground from the campus,” Turnbull stated.
He accused the ministry of acting without compromise and said repeated efforts to engage were ignored.
“I wrote this letter to them around the 19th. There was no response,” he said. “I followed up with calls and WhatsApp. No response. And then today my phone is bombarded with calls from the ministry,” Turnbull stated.
Turnbull rejected claims that safety concerns justified removal, pointing instead to the existing structure.
“That ‘boat’ that is there is not safe,” he said. “As recent as Monday, I got reports that a student fell off that boat and got injured,” Turnbull stated.
He said the community was prepared to fund the removal of the old playground, while the donor would cover the cost of constructing the new one.
“The donor is willing to pay for the construction and erection of the new playground because they want to benefit the school and this community,” he said.
Turnbull accused the minister of exerting control rather than seeking a resolution. “It’s not about policies, it is about them and the minister trying to be bull-headed and manipulate persons to do what she wants because she wants to be the boss,” he said.
“I would rather partner with my honourable colleague, who’s my cousin, as an At-large rep than turn the community of Cane Garden Bay against her,” Turnbull added. He said police later warned him that his vehicle would be removed if he did not comply with instructions, but insisted he would continue to stand with the community.
“I am going to continue to stand on principle,” Turnbull said. “This is for the benefit of the students of the Cane Garden Bay community,” he added.
Copyright 2026 BVI News, Media Expressions Limited. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or distributed.




















Sharie is a control freak. She has everyone on pins and and needles in her ministry and in the schools. She and that hard back Crab have the place in one mess.
The word you are looking for is “incompetent”. Always was, always will be. Why they kept voting for her is down to the epidemic called ‘being gullible’. Stop putting incompetent people in power. They do not know how to use it properly. Stop it.
Thank the Lord all of this happened so the residents of this country can see for themselves the pettiness that goes on with Politics and the ruling class of the VI.
Yeah wait until everyone learns who behind All 13 Must Go.
Tell us we want to know !
Why she didn’t send back the belongers for her boy friend and the money to pay for credit cards and brakes? She sending back everything except that.
lol lol lol
Sharie is a child and her opportunistic CEO is no different.
This is SAD!. The fact that you chose to use Sharie’s mother’s name as your discussion title speaks volumes. It suggests that you either know the family personally or are closely connected to them. You’ve watched this woman grow from a child into an adult.
To the younger generation in the BVI, remember, sometimes growth requires stepping away from what’s familiar and venturing beyond home. Sadly, personal growth can be difficult when surrounded by those bound by envy and jealousy. This kind of behavior reflects the mindset of “you can succeed but not more than me”. Calling an adult a child is both disrespectful and appalling. She is Violet and Mr. de’Castro’s daughter, not yours.
Please show me one instance where this guy is not involved in confusion. 12 years and nothing but confusion.
2 cousins at that
it is very hard to “give ” to the school system, they want you to give it to the authority and not the seperate school that the donation is intended for, same thing happened to me but i just phoned and told them the donation was made privatley without any media involvement and so they got to keep all the muisc equipment
Shameful that petty politics and photo ops are the bedrock of the current minister of education! While Sharie is in Finland lapping it up with her gal pals on tax payers dimes – the Ivan Dawson Primary school students have to continue to suffer and be degraded further by her lack of humility and professionalism.
Sharie do you truly care about education or is it just a job that has perks you have become addicted to? I think the latter by your words, deeds and actions.
The Premier should have fired you a long time ago and reshuffled his cabinet as you are underperforming yet globetrotting almost monthly!
How come Lesmore aint had to go thru all dah bull?
But Mitch knows the routine. Nothing moves unless Sharie is on hand for the ceremonial handover and the photo‑op she needs.
the minister looked petty and childish, this was for the kids, smh
Mitch needs to follow the protocols for contributing thr play ground
Why didn’t he complete the paperwork like all the othets who contributed lsygrpund
He feels he is above the policies that governs these things.
He is creating confision and eanys to make the Minisyry look bad.
Mich is a hypocrite and is looking political sympathy
As a leader, do the toght thing . Structures ate in place to guide all of us Stop
It
You are correct. The Jezebel spirit over him to manipulate and originate confusion and play politics is so obvious. The entitlement is hilarious. I would have loved to see him try this when his Alliance leader was still the Minister of Education. Stop playing with the public’s emotions to set up your other Alliance member as the better option as Minister of Education next election.
Ask teachers of Clarence Thomas high school how they enjoyed all the Minister did for them back then. A lot is being done for youth and education under this minister. We ignore too much positive and label it as boring, while celebrating bad and trying to disguise it as good. We need to admit that we do not celebrate the positive events and achievements like we should because our favorite pass time is gossip, chaos and slander.
Stop liking and hating people because narcissistic influencers tell you to in their rants.
People…..you cannot just accept donations. You have to follow the policy. We need to do due diligence on the donor to make sure that it’s “clean” and then ensure that contracts etc. are not awarded due to generosity of ppl. Genuine donations accepted but through a proper process. Post COI it is a must that we follow the policy prior to accepting donations. It’s not about a photo opt but about good governance. Don’t be gullible!
You are correct, school systems do normally have polices on donations. Since your enlightened on good governance practices of the BVI, where or what is this policy/procedure (in written form) you mention? Are there forms?
I would be impressed if there was one and more impressed if it were followed and could be executed in a timely manner.
Exactly my point! We keep acting as if we live in a cowboy town. Protocols exist for a reason, to prevent unforeseen or unintended consequences. A donor can’t want to give anonymously when the COI was just all up in BVI files. We need to STOP, think carefully and make wise decisions instead of reacting based on emotions.
Based on the no response behavior from the child Minister, signaling no respect for the district member, I would say that the rep. Did all that he could.
So Marlon can go by the Airport and drop off donated stuff because the Airport is in the 8th District, despite it being under BVIAA and by extension, MCW? Dr Dawson can do what he want at the West End Ferry Dock because he is the rep for the 1st despite the port being under BVIPA/MCW? The donation is a good gesture, the actions thereafter were very stupid and never should have come to this. Both Mitch and Sharie are young, attention seeking people that would be complete nobodies if they were not elected so let us stop pretending to be shocked at their continued grand standing and childish behavior. Kids will always be kids!
Maybe the minister for the area might have answered him, even if the answer was not accurate. Respond.
Calling on the People of the BVI to wake up and Stop playing Church. Serious Prayers are needed in this Little territory. This is what Politics have come to in This territory. When you put spoiled Children to Do the Work of Adults, This is what you get. This is a cause for Protest. We need our HOA free up of these set of spoiled Children. People of the BVI, The Signs are revealing. Pray, Pray, Pray. Prayers are needed for this BVI. Something Terrible is Coming!!! Pray without ceasing. This is NOT a Fear Mongering Tactic. Something Serious is about to affect the BVI… Remember this Date. We are No different than other Countries. Pastors, Bishops, Christians STOP Playing Church. God is getting ready for This territory. STOP waiting on Grand Signs. This is the beginning of Sorrow!. BVI is NOT exempt from God”s Wrath. There is Something Coming Very Soon for This BVI. The Signs are everywhere and They are showing TROUBLE. No Joke. Call it what you Like: False Prophet. Procrastination. Drunkeness. Whatever. Just remember the Story of Noah. BVI This is a Warning… WICKED!! WICKED!! WICKED!!!
I remember when my child was in school there were always complain of no toilet paper, tissue and when covid came, hand sanitizer. I wouldn’t name the school but several parents use to donate by the case. None of us never went through the education department. The principal and teachers use to be so glad.
So does donations only matters when is big and expensive things? I listened to Decastro today and was disgusted. They wilfully went and ordered a play ground to reject the one that was being donated just so she can be at the front of the cutting of the ribbon ceremony.
BVI people petty. Hope she got the same energy when it raining and the school flooding out
It seems like the education system is falling apart. As an educator I can testify that Sharie and C run the schools with an iron fist. The teachers and principals seem to be afraid of them . Mrs. C is a very vindictive and spiteful person. So is Ms. Sharie. They are one and the same. Then they promote people with similar personalities. Check the recent principals at EAPS, especially Elmore’s [family]. She’s a terrible person.She wants to talk to people how she want and has no manners or respect. Think she’s the big bad wolf. She should not be allowed to lead people. She needs to go for sure. But she was promoted by C even though she knows her nasty disrespectful ways. Education needs to be taken from Sharie and C needs to go with her. They are making a mock in the ministry and schools. Being a bully and disrespectful are not leadership styles. Can’t wait to see both of them gone. She needs to take some of the principals too.
With all that time of conversation, all she had to say was the Ministry ordered equipment already. Story done without confusion. I believe Mitch.
I doubt,between the two of them, Sharie and Mitch could arrange a proper goat humping.
Now that everyone e is looking, Sharie, get the playground replaced with 30 days. Mitch, that huge pothole in the road in front of the school is almost as big as a couple church collection plates. Let’s see if you can get that filled before someone disappears into it.
Such a shame them so call pastors here in the bvi is creating so much problems and confusion instead of doing the most high work hmmmm.