BVI News

Virgin Islanders allowing foreign cultures to dominate their own

Respected historian Dr Charles Wheatley said many cultural practices of BVIslanders still exist but are no longer dominant in the territory because foreign cultures have been given prominence.

Residents and local historians have long expressed concerns about the erasure of cultural practices that were originally passed down from the foreparents of BVIslanders.

But Dr Wheatley said BVIslanders have a responsibility to ensure that their culture remains dominant when foreign ways of life are introduced to the community.

“In any community, culture grows, it’s not static. You have dominant features and recessive features. It is up to the people who have the dominant culture to remain dominant when a sub-culture comes in,” Dr Wheatley explained recently on the Omoja radio show hosted by Edu En Ka.

“What has been happening here is that BVIslanders have allowed subcultures to dominate their culture. So instead of being dominant, in some cases, they (BVIslanders) are the subculture — they are recessive.”

As an example, Dr Wheatley said the Rise and Shine festival which originated in the BVI, is no longer celebrated in its original form because the community has substituted some of its elements with those of Carnival, which is foreign to the BVI.

“We used to have a tramp called Rise and Shine. In those days it wasn’t a Carnival, it was a festival. Rise and Shine has certain characteristics. We’ve allowed our festival to change because there were others coming from places with a Carnival. We rejected our festival and accepted the Carnival characteristics,” the long-time educator explained.

BVIslanders have been fighting for years to retain important aspects of their culture amid a growing expat population with a variety of foreign cultural practices.

Historians say there is a need to document and preserve BVIslanders’ unique culture and add it to the local curricula so students can gain more knowledge of the people who’ve built the Virgin Islands.

Shares

Copyright 2024 BVI News, Media Expressions Limited. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or distributed.

28 Comments

Disclaimer: BVI News and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the comments below or other interaction among the users.

  1. walked with their dirty habits says:

    Them island people messed up ah we thing

    Like 13
    Dislike 29
  2. Rasheda says:

    Culture evolves. Everybody like to wuk up. In with the new out with the old. Tola not the same. Guns and violence at festival and carnival now.

    Like 14
    Dislike 15
  3. Miss P says:

    I want to comment but I will keep my mouth shut this morning because ayo know if I open my mouth all h**l broke loose.

    Like 11
    Dislike 2
  4. SMH says:

    TRUTH!!!

    Like 8
    Dislike 1
  5. Reality Check says:

    I am confused in that the BVIslanders are expat as well and brought their culture, becoming dominant over the existing population. As Dr. Wheatley stated, “In any community, culture grows, it’s not static”, then why are the changes reflecting a changing population unusual, or even a cause for concern? That growth reflecting population change is to be celebrated as a rejection of stagnation. As Matt Ridley explained in his seminal The Evolution of Everything: “We understand now that all enduring structures above the level of the simplest atoms, and up to the brain and society, are the results of, and can be explained only in terms of, processes of selective evolution…”

    Like 17
    Dislike 6
  6. Hmmm says:

    Power verses influence, the stronger will win everytime. It is not our fault if tolans want to be like us.

    Like 8
    Dislike 12
  7. Photo says:

    Interesting choice of photo to accompany this article!

  8. Dr Doctor says:

    Great photo! Nothing says BVI culture like 2 strangers dry humping each other in public. What a way to celebrate. At least they have their masks on! Get it girl!

    Like 14
    Dislike 2
  9. Vague much? says:

    “Rise and Shine has certain characteristics.” A good historian would have been able to define those “certain characteristics” I would have thought.

    Like 12
    Dislike 2
  10. Deliberate importation says:

    At every August Festival we import various cultures from around the region and sometimes even the continent. We birth our children in a foreign culture, send them to school in a foreign culture, and then when they come back they bring traits of those cultures back. Finally, it would be
    interesting to poll the age group that holds these views. The horse is out of the stable and we are trying to close the door.

    Like 12
    Dislike 3
  11. Waste if time says:

    They always wait until they miss the buss to come out and talk.

    Like 4
    Dislike 4
  12. jungle says:

    Those who value their culture keep it and respect it. We virgin islanders don’t. Simple as that. We don’t speak the same way we used to or eat the same way we used to or believe the same things we used to. We are not who we used to be so our culture has gone with the wind.

    Like 11
    Dislike 3
  13. I will rest my case says:

    HAVE EVER SEEN THIS WHEATLEY GUY IN A PARADE OR RISE AND SHINE?

    Like 5
    Dislike 5
  14. Resident says:

    I really have to agree with Dr Wheatley. I posted similar comments before and I am an expat. I have seen firsthand the cultural decline of FESTIVAL to CARNIVAL. This is not an insult to carnival and the countries that celebrate it. I have always maintain that the two activities need to be separated. Have the August Festival then have a carnival at a different time. There should be clear guidelines for each. One thing I will disagree with Dr Wheatley with is that the expats are not to blame for the change. The younger BVISLANDERS are. They totally embraced the carnival activities. I remember when Education Dept won best band one year there was a big hurrah because they were decently dressed. The bands that thought were better had the skimpy clothes and indecent behavior. Education is important and sticking to the rules and polices. We can’t be putting rules in place one year then removing them the next year.

    Like 17
  15. GTFOH says:

    It’s sad but true. Maybe the VI way is too boring for today’s generation of youths. Them want igbo and shayo.

    Like 7
    Dislike 4
  16. LB says:

    I bet if Ms. P had said this same thing everyone would kick up!

    Like 3
    Dislike 3
  17. PT09 says:

    @Hmmm, Your head is to big for your body if you think that tolans want be be like you all, it’s a small group of you that dont have have no respect for anyone, that group shouldn’t be in the BVI because you are vulgar and rude.

    Like 9
    Dislike 6
  18. Sky says:

    A bet one a ayo family deh with a island man
    Even have a baby for a island man/ woman!!
    Set a clown

    Like 4
    Dislike 6
  19. Correct says:

    The very low class simulation of sex performed by every female over the age of 13 attending the rise and shine is certainly not our culture.

    Like 7
    Dislike 1
  20. Um says:

    Did he state what the BVI style Rise and Shine should be instead?? He is what 80? Culture changes as the world changes. When he was in his 20’s women weren’t allowed to do anything. The BVI has advanced 200 years in 60 years, of course culture changes as technology changes.

    Like 3
    Dislike 5
  21. long bush possee says:

    Ken Boynes xmas festival was more colorful and spectacular…no vulgarity

    Like 2
    Dislike 1
  22. Jon says:

    Exactly.

    Like 1
    Dislike 1
  23. What culture says:

    The culture you refer to is dead and there’s something new address that from clinging onto something we can’t relate too and attempt to start a new more positive culture

    Like 1
    Dislike 3
  24. Pure evilness says:

    everything happen here is always the UK or the island people them fault , yeah rite ,,( we have asked Mr E Leonard about the name (island people came from and what was the purpose of it ??? ) but he playing hide & seek so since you are a historian can you please enlighten us, on why , after all our ancestors came from the same place and were separated and sent to different countries / island of which TORTOLA is one ) aren’t we one Caribbean brothers nand sisters ? or did some flew down from Africa

    Like 3
    Dislike 1
  25. Best Bet says:

    BVI culture is not promoted and your best bet is to take on some of the expat culture. Your own people don’t even support the little cultural activities y’all have. Face the facts BVI will be like St.Marten,a melting pot of expats. Best you embrace them mixture of different people and cultures. Otherwise if you want to preserve your culture start investing in it,ensure your schools teach it and the traditional things from the BVI are pass on to your people.

    Like 4
    Dislike 1
  26. Dead Culture or No Culture says:

    “In any community, culture grows, it’s not static. You have dominant features and recessive features. It is up to the people who have the dominant culture to remain dominant when a sub-culture comes in,” Dr Wheatley explained recently on the Omoja radio show hosted by Edu En Ka.

    A total contradiction. No one can over-ride culture. If culture exist – it prevails. The expats who come here have culture – so it prevails.

    If you are in the midst of culture, you adapt to that culture. If you have no culture – there is nothing for one to adapt to.

    Accept that you are Caribbean – and your Culture will flow. You are not American – therefore stop trying to be American and embrace your Caribbean Culture.

  27. Loool says:

    Nothing new, since yall grinding yall own families, what’s worst???

    Like 5
    Dislike 2
  28. Jane says:

    Tortola people like to call other Caribbean people island people. I wonder if they know Tortola is an island to

Leave a Comment